Jackson Cionek
18 Views

The Same Body, Different Ground - Who Are We When We Must Relearn How to Move?

The Same Body, Different Ground - Who Are We When We Must Relearn How to Move?

APUS, neuroplasticity, and Metanoia: what motor adaptation experiments reveal about the Body-Territory as we move from condition A to B and return to A.

When the Ground No Longer Responds as Expected

Imagine walking along a familiar sidewalk. Your steps happen almost automatically while you talk, observe your surroundings, or think about your next appointment.

Now imagine that the ground begins moving differently beneath each foot.

You try to walk normally, but something has changed. Your body must discover how to regain balance and coordinate its movements.

After some time, you learn to handle this unfamiliar condition.

Then the ground returns to normal.

Surprisingly, your first steps may still be different.

The environment has returned to its previous condition. But have you returned to the same state?

This question connects Amy Bastian's research, highlighted at Neuroscience 2026, with BrainLatam's hypothesis of APUS, extended proprioception, and Metanoia, the reorganization that participates in constructing the perceptual present.

The Experiment: Two Legs, Two Speeds

Researchers use a treadmill with two independently controlled belts, known as a split-belt treadmill. Each leg can walk on a surface moving at a different speed.

Initially, both belts move at the same speed. The participant walks normally.

Then one belt accelerates.

During the first steps, an asymmetry emerges. The organism must adjust stance timing, step length, and coordination between the legs.

However, not every adjustment represents learning.

Some responses occur immediately and disappear when the perturbation ends. Others develop gradually and produce subsequent effects.

After walking for several minutes with different belt speeds, both belts return to the same speed.

This is when a particularly interesting result appears: the person may temporarily exhibit an asymmetry opposite to the one initially produced by the perturbation.

This phenomenon is known as an aftereffect.

The nervous system had adjusted its predictions about movement and now needs to recalibrate them again.

The experiment therefore distinguishes responding to a change from learning through a change.

A→B→A: Returning Without Fully Returning

We can describe the experiment through three moments.

A — Initial condition: the organism walks on two surfaces moving at equal speeds.

B — Perturbation: one belt changes speed, requiring new coordination strategies.

A' — Return: both belts move at equal speeds again, but movement still reveals effects of the previous experience.

The physical condition A may have returned. However, the organism's functional state does not necessarily become immediately identical to its initial state.

This interval offers an opportunity to investigate our Metanoia hypothesis.

At BrainLatam, we propose that reorganization participates in the very process of constructing the present, while the Body-Territory encounters changing conditions.

This does not mean that the experiment directly demonstrates Metanoia. It means that the experiment provides measurable variables through which the hypothesis could be tested.

Amy Bastian: Learning Is Not Simply Correcting Errors

At SfN 2026, Amy Bastian presented Learning to Move: What Development and Neurological Injury Reveal.

Her scientific work investigates how children and adults acquire motor skills, how neurological injuries affect learning, and why different learning mechanisms respond differently to perturbations.

In locomotor adaptation experiments, the cerebellum plays an important role in updating predictions about the sensory consequences of movement.

When the feedback received differs from what was expected, the nervous system can use that discrepancy to modify future motor commands.

But the research also reveals an important problem: learning in one situation does not guarantee that the learning will transfer to another.

Someone may adapt to a treadmill yet show limited transfer when walking overground.

Research published in 2024 suggests that the nervous system may recalibrate components that generalize across contexts alongside components that remain more specific to the treadmill.

This distinction is fundamental.

The brain does not necessarily construct one universal solution. It can organize responses that depend, at least partly, on the conditions under which learning occurred.

APUS: Situatedness Changes the Movements Available to Us

Conventional proprioception provides information about body position and movement through specialized sensory systems.

Our hypothesis of APUS, extended proprioception, seeks to broaden the question toward Estar: being situated in different circumstances.

We do not propose that biological proprioception alone represents the full complexity of social and territorial experience.

Instead, we propose investigating how proprioceptive information integrates with other bodily and environmental processes to support situated experience.

The same person walks on a treadmill, crosses a street, climbs a staircase, or accompanies someone else.

Each encounter changes the demands, predictions, and possibilities for action.

The Body-Territory maintains its material continuity while its functional relationships change.

APUS invites us to ask: which characteristics of Situatedness modify the recruitment of networks responsible for movement?

And which changes remain when the situation ends?

Tamar Makin: Plasticity Also Has Limits

Another SfN 2026 presentation deserves particular attention: Stable Brains in Changing Bodies: Rethinking Plasticity in Sensory Cortex, by Tamar Makin.

In 2025, Makin and colleagues published a particularly thought-provoking longitudinal study.

The researchers followed three people before and after arm amputation, using functional magnetic resonance imaging to examine cortical representations of the hand and lips.

Despite the profound bodily change, the representations examined remained remarkably stable throughout follow-up.

The findings challenge the simplified interpretation that the adult brain necessarily reorganizes large cortical territories whenever it loses a source of sensory information.

Plasticity does not mean unlimited transformation.

An organism can learn new ways of acting while preserving important aspects of its neural organization.

This observation matters for our concepts because it prevents us from confusing Metanoia with any cerebral change, or interpreting stability as the absence of adaptation.

Perhaps we need to investigate precisely how continuity and transformation coexist.

The Body-Territory Is Not a Representation on a Screen

We can watch a video of someone walking on a split-belt treadmill. The image shows movements, but it does not reproduce the full bodily conditions of that encounter.

A screen presents a fragment of a fragment: a selected representation that the observer interprets again.

Walking involves forces, balance, contact, sensory predictions, and bodily adjustments experienced within the situation itself.

Within 5D Consciousness, we propose three spatial dimensions of the measurable materiality of the Body-Territory, one dimension of Movement, and one dimension of Qualia.

Movement includes the materialized transformations of internal processes involved in perception. Qualia refers to the experiential prominence associated with attention.

EEG, motion analysis, and magnetic resonance imaging record measurable aspects of these relationships, not the totality of subjective experience.

This distinction also connects with the Damasian Mind: the organism perceives and acts in relation to the conditions necessary for its own regulation.

What Happens When Another Person Changes Our Path?

Let us return to the person learning to walk under unfamiliar conditions.

What if they observe someone else? What if they receive guidance? What if they learn from someone who has already experienced that difficulty?

The encounter may modify their strategies, expectations, and learning possibilities.

This opens a path toward the Relational Connectomic Reserve, a hypothesis we will develop later in the series.

We are not claiming that another person's presence automatically activates anatomical reserve connections.

We are asking whether certain relationships allow the recruitment of functional strategies that were not expressed under the same conditions during an individual attempt.

We must also distinguish imitation, instruction, temporary facilitation, and learning that persists after the encounter.

The Next Experiment

Imagine a motor adaptation protocol combining movement analysis, balance measurements, muscle activity, and appropriate brain recordings.

First, we investigate individual performance.

Then, we compare learning through independent trial and error, observation of another person, and face-to-face collaboration.

Finally, all participants return to the original condition without assistance.

We measure individual differences, aftereffects, retention, and transfer to another situation.

Our hypothesis predicts that different kinds of encounters may produce different adaptation trajectories. But the experiment could also demonstrate that certain tasks depend predominantly on individual learning mechanisms.

That result would be equally important.

The Same Body Never Encounters Exactly the Same Ground

Amy Bastian's research shows that learning to move involves distinct mechanisms, prediction errors, and context dependence.

Tamar Makin's findings demonstrate that profound bodily changes do not necessarily imply large-scale reorganization of cortical maps.

Together, these studies encourage us to move beyond a simplistic opposition between stability and plasticity.

The Body-Territory can preserve existing organizations while modifying its possibilities for action.

APUS seeks to understand Situatedness within these transformations. Metanoia proposes investigating what happens during the transition between situations, not merely afterward.

A Decolonial Neuroscience can expand these questions by considering different bodies, environments, and learning histories without abandoning the requirement for scientific evidence.

And perhaps the treadmill experiment leaves us with an even greater question:

When the ground becomes the same again, what remains different in our ways of Being, Situatedness, and Perception?


Annotated References

1. Bastian, A. J. (2026). Learning to Move: What Development and Neurological Injury Reveal. Neuroscience 2026, Society for Neuroscience.

This lecture highlighted different mechanisms of motor learning, including processes related to errors, rewards, development, and neurological injury. It provides the starting point for this blog: understanding why adaptation is not a single process and why rehabilitation may need to engage preserved learning mechanisms when others are impaired.

2. Understanding mechanisms of generalization following locomotor adaptation (2024).

This experimental study, associated with Amy Bastian's research field, investigates how learning transfers between split-belt treadmill walking and overground locomotion. Its findings support the interpretation that adaptation involves both generalizable components and context-specific mechanisms. It provides a scientific foundation for asking what APUS might contribute to understanding Situatedness across different environments.

3. Hagen, A. C. & Fling, B. W. (2026). Locomotor adaptation on a split-belt treadmill: mechanisms, modulation, and clinical utility. Journal of Neurophysiology, 135.

This review explains how some gait parameters respond immediately to perturbations while others exhibit gradual adaptation and aftereffects. It discusses the contributions of the cerebellum, sensory prediction errors, and the difficulties of transferring adaptation to everyday walking. It helps operationalize the A→B→A experimental design without interpreting every movement change as evidence of lasting plasticity.

4. Schone, H. R. et al., including Tamar R. Makin (2025). Stable cortical body maps before and after arm amputation. Nature Neuroscience, 28, 2015–2021.

Following three individuals before and after amputation, the researchers found stability in the cortical representations examined. The findings challenge assumptions of automatic cortical remapping and provide an essential counterpoint to the idea of unlimited plasticity. For Metanoia, they raise an important question: can behavioral and experiential changes occur without equivalent large-scale changes in neural maps?

5. Makin, T. R. (2026). Stable Brains in Changing Bodies: Rethinking Plasticity in Sensory Cortex. Neuroscience 2026, Society for Neuroscience.

This presentation brought together questions concerning amputation, congenital limb absence, and technologically augmented motor capabilities. Its contribution lies in distinguishing representational stability, functional adaptation, and brain reorganization. This distinction protects the APUS hypothesis from automatically equating every change in circumstances with anatomical remapping.

6. Lent, R., Tovar-Moll, F. & Szczupak, D. (2026). The secret connections of the brain: a connectomic reserve for neuroplasticity?. Brain.

The Brazilian Connectomic Reserve hypothesis offers a perspective on structural resources potentially available for neural reorganization. In this blog, it introduces a question that will be explored further through Jiwasa: might certain bodily experiences and social encounters facilitate the functional recruitment of previously unexpressed possibilities? This is a proposed extension, not a conclusion established by gait adaptation experiments.

7. Damasio, A. (2021). Feeling & Knowing: Making Minds Conscious.

This work provides a perspective on feelings, bodily regulation, and the construction of conscious experience. It offers a conceptual dialogue with APUS, Tekoha, and 5D Consciousness, particularly by distinguishing measurable bodily processes from subjective experience. It does not constitute experimental validation of BrainLatam's original concepts.

BRAINLATAM · GRAND SUMMARY SfN 2026 · BLOG 02 · ENGLISH EDITION




#eegmicrostates #neurogliainteractions #eegmicrostates #eegnirsapplications #physiologyandbehavior #neurophilosophy #translationalneuroscience #bienestarwellnessbemestar #neuropolitics #sentienceconsciousness #metacognitionmindsetpremeditation #culturalneuroscience #agingmaturityinnocence #affectivecomputing #languageprocessing #humanking #fruición #wellbeing #neurophilosophy #neurorights #neuropolitics #neuroeconomics #neuromarketing #translationalneuroscience #religare #physiologyandbehavior #skill-implicit-learning #semiotics #encodingofwords #metacognitionmindsetpremeditation #affectivecomputing #meaning #semioticsofaction #mineraçãodedados #soberanianational #mercenáriosdamonetização
Author image

Jackson Cionek

New perspectives in translational control: from neurodegenerative diseases to glioblastoma | Brain States